Featured 'Bayonet to sickle' sculpture: 2 Qs

Discussion in 'Art' started by Potteryplease, Dec 4, 2025 at 7:51 PM.

  1. Potteryplease

    Potteryplease Well-Known Member

    I got this sculpture at a recent estate sale. I think it's a repurposed bayonet, one that looks old.

    The famous Bible quote is hand-written on what sure looks like a manila folder, then scissored and glued to the wood base.

    The artist is a local guy: https://portlandopenstudios.wordpress.com/2010/09/15/robert-mcwilliams-visionary-outsider/

    Two questions:

    1. I want to remove the quotes on paper, as I think they make it look cheap and maybe even over-explain it. Should I?

    2. Would it have been more interesting (or valuable!) as a bayonet, and, if so, does that mean there's absolutely no hope for humanity?


    (from the end of the 'mount', the blade is 22" / 56cm curved)

    Thanks!

    IMG_5462.jpeg IMG_5463.jpeg IMG_5464.jpeg IMG_5465.jpeg IMG_5466.jpeg IMG_5467.jpeg IMG_5468.jpeg

    Gonna also tag @the blacksmith
     
  2. Bronwen

    Bronwen Well-Known Member

    I'm torn between leave it as the artist intended & relocate it to the bottom.
     
  3. Potteryplease

    Potteryplease Well-Known Member

  4. Bronwen

    Bronwen Well-Known Member

    After bothering to look at the article at the link you posted, I see that his pieces generally are of this punning, concept driven sort, but did not spot in any of the photos explanatory labels prominently placed. I had been going to say that if you had an eye to its future value to a collector, you should leave it in original condition. However, I am not now very sure this is the original condition, although I don't doubt the Bible verse goes with the work. Can the label be removed intact, without marring the underlying wood?
     
  5. Potteryplease

    Potteryplease Well-Known Member

    I got it at his personal estate sale (as well as other stuff), so I know it's not been added to by someone else. It's his handwriting too.

    The paper is pretty 'on there.'

    Thanks for the feedback, btw!
     
  6. Bronwen

    Bronwen Well-Known Member

    Then I think it had better stay there.
     
  7. Potteryplease

    Potteryplease Well-Known Member

    You know, I could probably fashion a kind of wood 'frame' to sit around the outside of the base, one that would conceal the quotes without damaging them. That might be a (literal!) work around.
     
    Bronwen likes this.
  8. 2manybooks

    2manybooks Well-Known Member

    I think the text should stay as the artist intended.

    I was just going to suggest something like that.
     
  9. evelyb30

    evelyb30 Well-Known Member

    I'd probably leave it; I think he did that with a fountain pen. To me, it's part of the work.
     
  10. Potteryplease

    Potteryplease Well-Known Member

  11. Roaring20s

    Roaring20s Well-Known Member

    Are we sure that it's the artist that wrote and applied the paper?
     
  12. charlie cheswick

    charlie cheswick Well-Known Member

    i get the impression the artist really wanted to explain his thought process, and felt strongly enough to add that

    would it look better without ....... yep

    would i remove it............hmmmm i dunno (tricky one) ;)
     
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page