Featured Cut Glass Cologne bottle ID help

From my father’s glass collection. Can anyone identify this? I think it is a cologne bottle with fan and diamond motifs. (The closest I have found is Libbey Corinthian c. 1910 ABP on ETSY, but the Libbey has a Hobstar in one view of the side & a signature.) Could this be American Brillant Period? Another Libbey pattern? What is it?

Measurements: 4 ¼ inches high with stopper, 3 ¼ inches high bottle without stopper, c. 3 1/8 inches wide/diameter. Stopper is c. 1 3/8 inch long, but the shank is broken so that is not the original length.

The ETSY ad said, “Replacement Stopper,” which led me to wonder: Which is worse for value: a replacement stopper or a stopper with a broken shank?

Thank you very much for your insights.

 

Imho: if what you have is original, broken or not, it's better than a replacement...unless that replacement is identical to the original, an' in better condition.

That is a very lovely bottle, even if it were without a stopper!

 

My guess is that is not the original stopper, but think you're right about its being a cologne bottle for a vanity top.

 

The stopper looks out of proportion. Pretty bottle though.

 

That may be because the missing shank causes it to sit lower in the bottle, or it may be the angle of the photo. When I aimed straight at the bottle the star on the bottom showed through and looked like it was on the side. I thought the most important thing for ID was to show the cut patterns on the side so I angled the photo upwards a bit. (If that makes any sense.)

 

I didn't even consider that it was not the original stopper. But I probably will not know for sure unless I can ID the bottle. Any ideas?

 

I can't say for sure one way or the other, but many of the cut glass & pressed glass bottles had the faceted stoppers. That is why you see so many in the listings that are selling a lot of assorted stoppers.

Some companies did engrave or acid etch numbers on both the stopper & bottle when they were made so that the correct stopper went into the correct bottle. The numbers are usually extremely tiny & could be found on the neck or the bottom of the bottle. Unfortunately, the number on the stopper is usually on the stub.