Slewed Horseshoe Punch Cups

Looking around in our storage building and came across a box lot of Slewed Horseshoe punch cups. Washing them today I realized I have 2 different types and am wondering who may have made each type. Any ideas?

The one on the left is slightly taller: 2 3/8" vs 2 1/4"

The one on the left's handle is notched, the other clear.

The one on the left has a patterned bottom, the other is clear.

I'm assuming both are repros, but curious about the differences.

Thanks for your help!
Janice

 

I know next to nothing about glass, but I did find a photo of an old punch set in crystal - alas, they don't show a good photo of the cups.
http://www.carnivalheaven.com/carnivalglass106/id57.htm

 

Thanks so much! From what I could read on the info, the original cup is the size of mine on the left. But the handle, although notched, on the original is slightly different. It swoops outward and upward, where mine is more C shaped.

I'm wondering who did the repros and if there's a way to date them?

 

I am fairly certain that L E Smith did that pattern as well. Perhaps check there?

 

Looks like Imperial also made that pattern?
Size is vastly different though - if these measurements are to be believed.
http://www.djantiques.net/item.php?id=5635

 

L. E. Smith still sells this pattern as 'Pinwheel' I think; & Indiana Glass sold the pattern as 'Pinwheel & Star' c1975. You might check these with a black light, tho' these are likely by Smith and Indiana Glass.
http://indianaglass.carnivalheaven.com/id239.htm
here's a link with an old USG catalog sheet with the original cup, which matches neither of these:
http://www.carnivalheaven.com/carnivalglass106/id57.htm

 

Thanks, TallCakes and Messilane. None of mine react to black light. I think they notched handle ones may be Indiana, but I haven't seen any with the clear handle and cup bottom.

 

U. S. Glass Co. made this originally, ca. 1900 and again in the 1950s. The punch cups may well have come from a new mold in the second iteration.

This does not contradict anything anyone else wrote, just adds to the confusion.