Featured Fairly rare TS find today. Opinions Please?

Hello All.
I found three of these Fostoria Baroque Iced Tea flat tumblers at the TS today. I had not seen the flat ones before. So I bought the 3 for $1.21 ea. (3.85 total). I could not find any comps on eBay, but I looked them up on the R site and they were asking $67 ea. for them. So I did an offer to sell to them and it came back they would pay me $29 ea. for them. ($87 total). Nice profit.
But my question is........should I just go ahead and send them off to replacements, or try them on eBay ?(and what to price them at)?
Opinions and comments most welcome!
Thanks All!

 

Personally, I wouldn't sell them to Replacements. From my understanding, you also have to pay the shipping cost. If they are willing to pay the shipping cost, then I might consider it

 

Thanks @*crs* I feel the same way. The shipping is a major factor. Plus selling to the R site would take a couple/few weeks to get my $$$$.
eBay would probably be quicker.
That said. since the R site wants $67 ea. for them. I wonder what I should price them at on eBay. somewhere between $29 and $67. My problem is finding sold comps. I did not find any listed on eBay either current or sold.

My thinking runs along the lines of.....to buy 3 from the R site would be just over $200. I might list them at $125 (about $40 ea.). Meaning an excellent profit for me and a good deal for the buyer.

 

I'm not sure that any of these are like yours or if they are recent sales plus there are more on worthpoint that are similar.

https://www.worthpoint.com/worthopedia/fostoria-baroque-flat-water-tumblers-4368396841

https://www.worthpoint.com/worthopedia/vintage-fostoria-baroque-crystal-3928192931

https://www.worthpoint.com/worthopedia/fostoria-baroque-7-flat-iced-tea-38905708080

https://www.worthpoint.com/worthopedia/fostoria-glass-co-baroque-2496-3833758716

 

Thank you @say_it_slowly . The second link is exactly what I have! I hope @Kronos will be willing to help with the sold look up for me!

VINTAGE FOSTORIA BAROQUE CRYSTAL THREE LARGE FLAT TUMBLERS ( HARD TO FIND).NICE! | #3928192931

 

More recent glassware that was quite common 20 yrs ago can def be worth some loot !
I've got a Stickley piece I'm prepping to sell and my friend, a Dealer for 35 yrs said the Kids aren't into this type of thing. I replied-'Yep, they like the MCM stuff right ?', he said-'No, the early 2000's stuff they grew up with.'
What era is early 2000's called ?

 

$27.50 (2022)

 

The Naughts...I think.

 

Thank You @Kronos

 

W00 H00! Woke up this morning to find that the 3 tumblers sold for $120~
Doing my happy dance!!

 

Awesome!!! Congratulation!

 

Nicely done