I'd say newish too. Victorians knew how to cast brass and wouldn't have let substandard items out of the factory.
Looks like glass from here too.
Once in a while they set the estimate low on purpose, but probably have a fair reserve on the item just in case. Sometimes though, they don't...
Front looks right, but the pin back looks later. Agree with Bear. Did you check the red plastic for bakelite yet?
Oops. Asleep at the switch, much?
The tester sounds off to me too, because while some Jerusalem crosses are set with glass, it's generally a substiture for blue zircon or amethyst.
I took a look at the auction, and I think the auction house was a tad low on its estimate.
Sure looks like one, but they have waterlily leaves under it. I think someone drew what the knew how to draw, whether it was the right thing or not.
I see a water lily and a koi fish, if that's any help.
It's a new artist today.
The OP's pin is a Halberd, if that helps any. That's the weapon design. Some gamer or fantasy fan out there would be all over it.
Separate names with a comma.