Message:

<p>[QUOTE=&quot;tagsale_notes, post: 13148748, member: 115485&quot;][USER=115381]@Capecodder[/USER] the maker came up blank because the name in the thread title is not quite what is on the plate, and the plate is the thing that unlocks this one. I zoomed your photo of the brass oval. It reads FROM THOMAS &amp; HOMANS, CABINET, UPHOLSTERY, CARPET &amp; BEDDING MANUFACTORY, ROCHESTER.</p><p><br /></p><p>Search &quot;Thomas and Homan&quot; and you get this thread and nothing else. Search Homan plus Rochester furniture and you get quite a lot, because that Rochester is Rochester in Kent, England, not Rochester NY.</p><p><br /></p><p>Two things in your own photos say England before any of the history does. Your dealer card calls it an English Victorian mahogany chest of drawers c. 1870, three long drawers and two short, which is exactly what the pictures show. And the paperwork with it is from Mentor Antiques, 7512 Post Rd, North Kingstown RI, whose whole line was &quot;Furnishings from England&quot;. They are closed now. So the chest came over as shop stock, and [USER=301]@komokwa[/USER] is right that the handwriting on the cards is American, because those cards are the Rhode Island dealer&#039;s, not the maker&#039;s. Both readings are correct, they are just describing different pieces of paper.</p><p><br /></p><p>The Rochester end. Franklin Homan of Rochester High Street was a furnisher, auctioneer and estate agent who also traded as a cabinet maker and upholsterer. He built new showrooms at the east end of the High Street around 1903 and the painted ghost signs on the gable walls still read Carpets, Furniture, Franklin Homan Ltd, the largest furnishing showrooms in the county. The firm wound itself up in 1938. Photographs and the history are here:</p><p><a href="http://paintedsignsandmosaics.blogspot.com/2012/02/franklin-homan-rochester.html" target="_blank" class="externalLink ProxyLink" data-proxy-href="http://paintedsignsandmosaics.blogspot.com/2012/02/franklin-homan-rochester.html" rel="nofollow">http://paintedsignsandmosaics.blogspot.com/2012/02/franklin-homan-rochester.html</a></p><p>Cabinet, upholstery, carpet and bedding is that exact trade, so Thomas &amp; Homans looks like the earlier partnership behind the later Franklin Homan Ltd.</p><p><br /></p><p>Now the family story, which is less silly than it sounds from this side of the ocean. Dickens bought Gad&#039;s Hill Place in 1856, about three miles from Rochester High Street. Franklin Homan furnished two bedrooms there on Dickens&#039;s written instructions, sent while he was touring America in 1867 to 1868, and after Dickens died in June 1870 Homan was the man the executors asked to value and sell the household effects. He also conducted the funeral. William R. Hughes covers the relationship in A Week&#039;s Tramp in Dickens-Land, pages 70 to 71.</p><p><br /></p><p>Be careful with what that does and does not prove. The plate proves the chest was supplied by the Rochester firm that furnished Dickens&#039;s bedrooms and later sold his estate. It does not prove Dickens owned this chest. Those are two different claims and only paper bridges them. What would bridge it: Kelly&#039;s Directory of Kent for the 1860s to 1880s, at Medway Archives in Strood, would date Thomas &amp; Homan as a partnership and therefore date your plate. The 1870 Gad&#039;s Hill sale catalogue would list lots. And you have the importer&#039;s notes, which is more than most people start with, so read them for a lot number or a house name rather than a famous one.</p><p><br /></p><p>The money side, honestly, because it is not what people expect. eBay is the wrong market for this and I can show you rather than assert it. I ran sold listings twice, last 90 days, &quot;victorian mahogany chest of drawers&quot; and &quot;antique chest of drawers mahogany victorian&quot;. Thirty three closed sales between them and every single one was a miniature, an apprentice piece, a dollhouse item or a spare knob. Full size case furniture does not post, so it does not close online, and an absence of results is not a low value, it is no signal at all. Run those two searches with Sold Items ticked and you will see the same thing.</p><p><br /></p><p>The one real number in front of us is on your own card: a struck out price that I read as $276.95, though it is scribbled over, so look at it yourself. That is a US dealer&#039;s asking price for it as plain English brown furniture, and that is fair. A two over three mahogany chest of about 1870 is the most common antique there is in Britain, and the market for it is a local saleroom, not a website. Yours is in far better condition than most, with the flame veneer, the carved corbels and the original turned knobs all there, and a key.</p><p><br /></p><p>So the wood is worth a few hundred. The plate and the paper trail are the only things that could ever be worth more than the wood, and unusually for inherited family lore, there is an actual mechanism behind this one instead of a wish. I would chase the directory dates first, they are cheap and they either open the door or shut it.[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>

Your name or email address:

Do you already have an account?

• No, create an account now.
• Yes, my password is:
• Forgot your password?

Stay logged in